Etsy Reviews: Pros, Cons, & Website Analysis
View the Website Audit Report for Etsy located in Richland County, South Carolina.
Website Analysis
See an overview of your website's report scores, including:
On-Page SEO, Links, Usability, Performance, and Social.
Top Recommendations:
1
Enhance Social Media Integration: Etsy should implement social sharing features directly on product pages to encourage users to share items on their social media profiles. This could significantly boost their social score and drive additional traffic from platforms like Instagram and Pinterest, which are vital for an e-commerce site.
2
Create Engaging Social Content: Develop and promote a content strategy focused on social engagement, such as user-generated content showcasing unique products and customer stories. This can help build a community around the brand and improve Etsy's visibility and engagement on social platforms.
3
Leverage Influencer Marketing: Collaborating with influencers who resonate with Etsy's audience can significantly enhance their reach and engagement. This strategy will not only strengthen their social presence but also help in building backlinks, supporting overall SEO efforts.
Organic Traffic
Organic Keywords
Website Overview Report for Etsy
Etsy.com exhibits an admirable performance with a well-optimized website scoring a full 100 in our audit evaluation. The site employs excellent on-page SEO techniques ensuring it is effortlessly searchable by search engines, boasts of strong external backlinks, a testament to its reputable online presence. Additionally, it showcases exemplary characteristics in terms of usability and performance, resulting in a compelling user experience. However, the report finds room for significant growth within the social aspect, currently standing at a score of zero. While Etsy's strong foundation has built a website that performs exceptionally well, leveraging social media platforms could provide an opportunity to further enhance brand visibility and inbound traffic, complementing their existing SEO efforts. This could potentially lead to an increase in user engagement, traffic, and ultimately conversions. We would be delighted to discuss this in further detail and explore strategies that can be employed to bolster Etsy's social media presence.
Etsy AI Search Ranking Scorecard
Relevance
Trustworthiness
Website Quality
Local Presence
Engagement
Connected Social Media Accounts for Etsy
Etsy Business Overview
Contact Etsy
Not Found
Not Found
Etsy Reviews
See the most recent reviews for Etsy on their Google Business Profile
Jessica S.
1
Etsy employees apparently can't think anymore!
I've been selling templates for years. Now I've moved to another country in August. I can't enter tax information for the new country in my Etsy shop. Etsy told me that this isn't possible in their system. I have to open a new shop!
I usually have 500 items!
In the new shop, I got 100 items for free. I had to pay the setup fee for this new shop! Now here's the kicker! Etsy suspended the new account that I was supposed to create! 😂 I supposedly violated rules. But no one can tell me which rule I violated. I only get the same responses from the same employees. Support and Etsy are really the worst! What a waste of time!
Elaine
1
I’m a small creator from Malaysia who opened an Etsy shop on October 5, 2025, selling my original digital wellness planner. I paid RM79 to list my first item, verified my details, and followed all policies.
Within days, Etsy suspended my account without clear reason. I appealed with full proof — product screenshots, emails, and mailbox verification — only to receive a generic denial from their “Trust & Safety” team, refusing to explain what I supposedly violated.
I was never refunded and was permanently banned from creating any new account. As a genuine first-time seller who invested sincerely, this experience was deeply discouraging and financially unfair.
I hope Etsy improves its transparency and communication with small sellers, especially international ones. Until then, I cannot recommend the platform to new creators.
Alexander Eriksen
1
Easily one of the worst sites to sell on. Their policies always favor buyers over sellers and their customer service is a complete joke. All of their customer service is done overseas by people who can barely speak english. They won't read your appeal or consider it at all, they just side with buyers and call it a day.
On top of that, my store was permenately suspended after four years and a 4.5 average rating as a shop. They claimed that this photo violated their prop weapon policy. They threw my appeal in the trash without reading it (again, probably because the customer service team don't speak english) and called it a day.
Etsy is an utter joke that cares absolutely nothing for sellers and treats them like garbage. Take your hard work and effort some place else if you're looking to sell.
Need more leads for Etsy?
Check out our WebID tool that helps identify visitors on your website real time.
See our customers winning
